When will my Mac play Blu-ray?
By Adam TURNER
My Leopard MacBook happily burns data to an external Blu-ray drive without the need for extra software, but why won't Apple let me watch Blu-ray movies?
Right now I've got LG's BE06 "Super Multi Blue All Format Drive" external Blu-ray player sitting between my Leopard MacBook and my Vista Media Centre. It's slow and clunky on Windows using the bundled CyberLink Hi-Def Suite, but it seems to play very nicely with the MacBook - burning Blu-ray discs much faster than with the Vista box.
I'm sick of fighting with my bipolar Vista Media Centre and I'm thinking of replacing it with a Mac mini running elgato's eyeTV. LG's BE06 Blu-ray burner would seem to be the perfect companion for a Mac mini and eyeTV. The BE06 Blu-ray burner retails for a mere $AU549 and the icing on the cake is that it also reads HD DVD discs. It happily played both formats on my Vista Media Centre, but it's a different story with the Mac.
The problems are two-fold - there's isn't Mac software available to decrypt commercial Blu-ray movies and there's doubt as to whether the Mac mini handles Blu-ray's annoying HDCP digital rights management requirements. It seems the Intel GMA 950 graphics chipset in the Mini is HDCP-certified, but HDCP isn't implemented in the OS X driver. Rumours would indicate the next Mac mini will feature the GMA X3100 graphics chipset, which is HDCP-compatible and currently used in the MacBook and the MacBook Air. If Apple comes to the party with drivers, it might solve my Blu-ray woes.
All this is bloody frustrating considering Apple was one of the first vendors to throw its support behind Blu-ray. To be fair, Cupertino didn't create this problem - but it's a rude shock to smug Apple lovers that a Vista box can do something their precious Mac can't.
We're stuck with Blu-ray and HDCP whether we like it or not, so Apple needs to bite the bullet and get on board. Don't give me the "Steve Jobs knows downloads are the future" line. It's little consolation to those of us that live in a country like Australia that can't get its act together regarding decent broadband. The fact the Australian iTunes Store doesn't sell movies yet is another slap in the face.
What I really need is a Mac equivalent of SlySoft's awesome AnyDVD HD. Maybe if we sacrifice a goat to the mighty DVD Jon he'll send some DRM-hacking love to the Mac community. Meanwhile I'm reluctant to buy a Mac mini if I eventually want to use it as Blu-ray media centre. Panasonic have just announced Australia's high-def hard drive recorder with a built-in Blu-ray burner, which is great news for suburbanites who previously had to choose between HD tuners and a DVD burner, but it's still no match for a tricked out media centre (when the media centre feels like working).
I'm guessing I should wait until Apple officially supports Blu-ray so I'm not stuck with HDCP-incompatible hardware (or at least driver-less hardware). There's talk of Jobs announcing a new home entertainment product at WWDC, lets hope it's a Blu-ray-enabled Mac mini or true PVR. With my luck it will be a crappy Blu-ray enabled Apple TV which, like most Apple products, will need to be hacked within an inch of its life before you can do anything interesting with it.
I guess I could BootCamp into Windows on the Mac mini and use AnyDVD HD to overcome the software and hardware issues, but it's a less than elegant solution. A better option would be to boot into Windows, use AnyDVD to rip a Blu-ray disc to the hard drive in a format that can be read by software like VLC, and then boot back into Leopard to play the now DRM-less movie file. Again, less than elegant.
The high-def war is over and to the victors should go the spoils. When will the spoils of Blu-ray's victory trickle down to the Mac faithful?
Subscribe to Hydrapinion
|
|
Recent Posts
Trackback address for this post
Trackback URL (right click and copy shortcut/link location)
13 comments
It is called OSXBMC!
I suspect we'll see full BR compatibility with Snow Leopard. It'll be the only "feature" in an OS-release not deemed to have features, except system optimization.
If there was a Mini that could play back Blu-Ray, I would get it right away! I don't understand why Apple keeps not putting their laptop tech into the ever-popular Mini on a regular basis. Also, I don't think X3100 would be a useful upgrade, as that chipset was considered end-of-life by Intel early this year (!). Either the HD4500, or the NVIDIA 9400M would be the right choice (and needed to actually play back Blu-Ray -- the X3100 can't do it).
After spending over $2000 on my computer, I should be able to play HD content on it, and sorry, iTunes offers zero HD content and Apple offers zero 1080p content besides movie trailers. The real reason that Apple is preventing Blu-Ray implementation on their computers is because they want to force their users to get all their content from Apple. They view Blu-Ray, which is now the HD DVD standard, as a competitor and so they are freezing it out on the Mac.
Oh man....! I'd sell my house for one..!
So what I'm hearing is there is no software to play blu ray movies on my mac even if I have an ext blu ray drive?
That's my understanding DM, even if you've got a Blu-ray drive you can play movies.
Adam
Subscribe to Hydrapinion
The digital lounge room is Adam Turner's office and it's also becoming the new battle ground for the hearts, minds and wallets of the masses. Reporting from the front line where PC converges with AV, Adam offers a view from the couch of everything from digital television and hard drive recorders to piracy and digital rights management.